Egyptian religious scholars: Islam forbids shedding civilian blood during Ramadan and Eid al-Fitr

[David Silverman/Getty Images] Egyptian ulama urged young people to seek guidance on fatwas and jihad from Al-Azhar or Dar al-Ifta.

[David Silverman/Getty Images] Egyptian ulama urged young people to seek guidance on fatwas and jihad from Al-Azhar or Dar al-Ifta.

  • COMMENT

    12

  • Print this article
  • increase decrease

Sheikhs and religious experts in Cairo called on Muslim youth to disregard fatwas issued by terrorist organisations that call on young people to carry out suicide operations in their countries during religious seasons such as the month of Ramadan, Eid al-Fitr and Eid al-Adha "to get a double reward".

In interviews with Al-Shorfa, they emphasised that killing civilians, harming national interests, and violating the sanctity of human life is forbidden according to consensus of the ulemas (religious scholars). Furthermore, they said the sin multiplies on religious occasions, which God created as cause for love, compassion, and giving among Muslims -- not for fighting.

Al-Qaeda affiliated groups in different Arab countries issued calls and fatwas for terrorist operations against the "West and its agents" during Ramadan and intensifying them during the days of Eid.

"Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula", the organisation's branch in Yemen, stepped up attacks against the government and the Yemeni Army in southern Yemen, killing dozens of soldiers and many civilians. AQAP members went so far as to carry out some of these operations against during iftars.

During the first days of Ramadan, the organisation published a statement online calling on al-Qaeda members and Muslim youth to target Yemeni soldiers and the Yemeni government to make them "repent before God". The organisation widened its list of targets by adding that "everyone who stands with the Yemeni government is an enemy of Muslims."

In late August, Al-Qaeda Organisation in the Islamic Maghreb broadcast a video calling on members to escalate terrorist operations against "French interests and governments in the Arab region co-operating with the West" during Ramadan and Eid al-Fitr.

Sheikh Gamal Qutb, former chairman of the Fatwa Committee at Al-Azhar in Cairo, told Al-Shorfa that Muslim youth must not surrender themselves and their minds to such invocations and fatwas, which could lead them to a dark path, not to heaven as al-Qaeda claims.

He said killing innocent civilians -- Muslim or non-Muslim -- is "forbidden according to consensus of the ulama and sheikhs, because it violates the sanctity of blood, which God forbid shedding in general and Muslim blood in particular ".

Qutb advised young people to use legitimate channels to obtain fatwas in such matters and to ask authorities in fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence) about the provisions of jihad.

"There are many means of jihad, including changing [that which is] evil with speech and the heart," he said.

Islamic scholar Khaled al-Jundi said that shedding the blood of Muslims and civilians in general is forbidden at all times and every occasion, and that the sin of doing so is multiplied for servants of God. He said that such fatwas have no legitimate grounds in Islam.

Al-Jundi said the real problem is that young people are getting such information and fatwas from the Internet without verifying their validity with religious authorities in jurisprudence and Islamic law at Al-Azhar and Dar Al-Ifta.

He advised young people to focus on working "to build their nations and change them with knowledge rather than violence, which will precipitate killing of the elderly and innocent children and women, whom the Islamic religion forbids killing".

Islamic Group theorist Dr. Nageh Ibrahim said any attacks on civilians, especially those that kill children, women, the elderly, Christian clergy, and the poor, are a major violation of the provisions of Islamic law, which prohibits killing these groups because they are not involved in fighting -- whether during Ramadan, Eid al-Fitr, or any other time of year.

In terms of the effect that such fatwas have in attracting more young people to join organisations affiliated with al-Qaeda, Dr. Ammar Ali Hassan, an researcher specialising in the affairs of Islamist groups, told Al-Shorfa that the impact of al-Qaeda and its various cells on the Internet declined significantly during the past three years.

Unlike previous years when al-Qaeda recruited members through the internet, as was the case in the bombings in London and Madrid, Hassan said several factors have caused the fatwas issued by al-Qaeda to lose credibility among the younger generation.

One of these factors is, "the inability of the organisation's senior leaders, such as Osama bin Laden and Dr. Ayman al-Zawahiri, to appear in the videos that are aired, as was the case between 2001 and 2006".

Among young people, "this gave an impression of the extent of weakness plaguing the organisation, so there is no reason for these fatwas to have any credibility," he said.

Hassan added that this coincided with "the success of security forces in Iraq, Afghanistan, and most Arab countries, such as Morocco, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt, in wiping out al-Qaeda in their countries through security campaigns, and through the ideological revisions that struck the ideological structure of any fatwa these groups could issue with respect to jihad and its provisions".

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS ARTICLE? (TOTAL VOTES: 8)

2 Dislike(s)

ADD A COMMENT (COMMENT POLICY) * DENOTES REQUIRED FIELD

* DENOTES REQUIRED FIELD

  • READER COMMENTS

    حسين شاهر

    2010-10-12

    First, I would like to inform you that I am somewhat acquainted with the science of the Hadith, given the fact that I used to study it in the past. Based on this, I feel that the science of the hadith is very extensive and it has its real men, who can distinguish what is right from what is wrong and the authentic Hadiths from the fabricated ones. Generally speaking, according to the science of the hadith, the hadiths are classified into more than ten ranks, according to their authenticity. As for the books of the hadith, there are four main books; two of them – al-Bukhari and Muslim – are at the highest degree of authenticity, which means that their contents are certainly sayings of the Prophet, peace be upon him. Those two books are accepted by all Muslims and the authenticity of the Hadiths included in them are unarguable and the scholars can depend on them to support their fatwas or to deduce certain religious ruling that was not specifically or explicitly stated in the Quran, which is the first source of legislation and fatwas in Islam. Then, we rely on the Hadith books that were compiled by al-Bukhari and Muslim if the issue in question was not explicitly stated in the Quran. The other two books that came after the two Saheehs of al-Bukhari and Muslim are Sunan Abu Dawood and Sunan al-Tirmidhi, which are also are authentic with the exception of some weak hadiths, because al-Bukhari and Muslim adopted extremely strict conditions to verify and judge the authenticity of the Hadiths included in their two books. As for the other two books of Hadiths, they adopted fewer conditions. This is the reason that they include Hasan – good – Hadiths in addition to the Saheeh – absolutely authentic – Hadiths, unlike the books of al-Bukhari and Muslim, which contain only the absolutely authentic Hadiths.

  • محمد المشعلاني

    2010-9-19

    The calls made by the Egyptian religious scholars are in total conformity with mind and reason. They said that murder is forbidden at all times, not only in the month of Ramadan; because the result is always the shedding of blood of innocent people. But maybe criminal acts in Ramadan are more serious, because they target fasting people in the month that is characterized by holiness and sacredness. Thus, I think that killing in such months or holy times is more sinful, and will bring more serious punishment on the perpetrators in the afterlife. We really need Egyptian religious scholars to continuously issue such positive fatwas and instructions, in order to prevent Muslims from following the fatwas issued by al-Qaeda terrorists, who claim knowledge of religion, and incite obscenity and immorality by carrying out terrorist acts against Muslims and others.

  • قيس الطائي

    2010-9-18

    The whole world has now realized, based on countless pieces of evidence, that many of the so-called clergy who issued evil fatwas, allowing the killing of people during the Friday sermons at the times of sectarianism, were the slaves of the frenzied dog, Saddam Hussein, who used to claim that he possessed the faith, courage and strength that he had lost after losing his family and honor. His family has left the homeland in humiliation, as a result of lying to people in the name of religion and Islam. Hence, I only found mercy in Christianity and Judaism, because they do not order the killing or slaughtering of people.

  • ناصر

    2010-9-15

    The Egyptian clergy always take the initiative and tackle the important issues that concern all people and benefit the religion seriously. Today, after the terrorist operations that we have seen and the targeting of innocents in Iraq or in any other country all over the world, the clergy took the initiative and called for halting these acts during the month of Ramadan and the other months. Such calls show the facts and form a barrier that prevents the youth from being convinced of the takfiri, extremist or Sufi thought and similar ideologies. Hence, the fatwas that prohibit joining terrorism or working with the terrorist organization are very important, because these are criminal organizations and nothing else, and they only seek to cause havoc and destruction.

  • سمير غانم احمد الموسوي

    2010-9-15

    The calls of the Egyptian clergy will save lives and lead to a decrease in the terrorist operations, especially the assassinations and the other terrorist acts, including the car bombs that kill many civilians. We in the Arab world, and all those who joined Al-Qaeda by default or under threat, need such advice and calls continuously. Such calls must be made by all the Muslim clergy, not only in Egypt, because killing the innocent Muslims during the month of Ramadan is no different from doing so at any other time. There must be continuous recommendations to end these terrorist acts.

  • قيس

    2010-9-15

    This call of the sheikhs, who support the criminal ideology of Al-Qaeda, will leave more innocent casualties in the future, because they call all members of this organization to blow themselves up in suicide attacks; this means that such attacks will increase in the coming period. This malicious call must be met with extra caution on the part of the security forces in all countries. These forces must be on the alert to handle any contingency and to prevent the insane terrorists from committing any attacks. In fact, the terrorists have taken leave of their senses and reason, and have followed these misleading calls and fatwas.

  • صقر العرب

    2010-9-11

    The Egyptian scholars: Killing civilians is prohibited under Sharia at any time of the year.

  • غانم ابو شوك

    2010-9-11

    I believe that they are positive fatwas, since they forbid bloodshed in all of the world’s countries, not only in one country, and this is evidence that the fatwas have come in order to ban the killing of civilians from any sects, religions and nations. Religious scholars and clerics in Egypt usually take a positive stance rejecting terrorist ideology, so as not to give any opportunity for terrorists to spread within Egypt and form a base there. In fact, these fatwas make it clear that terrorists do not have the right to target civilians at any time of the year, not only for one month, or that they perhaps forbid targeting civilians only in the holy month of Ramadan or Muharram, for example. The killing of Muslims in any month of the year, and at any time, is an enormous crime which is unforgivable by God before being punished by the law.

  • بنان سعيد البنا

    2010-9-11

    I think that terrorists have to consider the fatwas issued by senior clerics in Egypt, and all over the world, as a way to stop working with the terrorists of al-Qaeda, to leave them, and return to reason, to repent and not kill Muslims and civilians from all the world’s countries at any time of the year. In fact, the terrorists are not God’s representatives on earth, and neither the law nor religion gives them a fatwa that authorizes them to kill innocent people deliberately in the streets, since all clerics in Egypt and in the world have issued many fatwas that forbid the killing of civilians, making the children orphans and widowing the women. They killed children and women in crimes which are repeated more than once, as evidence of the heinous terrorism and its impurity.

  • محمد

    2010-9-10

    Shame on you, this is unbearable.

  • doaa

    2010-9-9

    O Lord, make Islam and the Muslims victorious.

  • محمد

    2010-9-9

    Shame on you! Teach the Muslims religion, the Quran and jurisprudence, instead of corruption, immorality and tourism. Where are the religious scholars who fear God and who do not fear the unjust ruler? Where are the revered Sheikhs, and how can we find someone like Abdul Hameed Kushk?