Fish poisoning causes scare in Egypt

A masked puffer fish swims near the Egyptian resort of Madinat Makadi near Hurgada. [Gleb Garanich/Reuters]

A masked puffer fish swims near the Egyptian resort of Madinat Makadi near Hurgada. [Gleb Garanich/Reuters]

  • COMMENT

    3

  • Print this article
  • increase decrease

Recent reports of fish poisoning sparked concern among Egyptian consumers, as several people died after eating puffer fish.

According to Majid Mustafa, a market observer for the Fisheries Authority, "six people died from eating the fish in 2012, raising the number of poisoning victims to 24 over the past three years."

"The market has been flooded with puffer fish, and we have also observed cases of food poisoning and deaths due to consumption in Alexandria, Ismailia and Suez," Mustafa told Al-Shorfa.

Puffer fishing is banned because of its poisonous nature, he said. Yet, despite the ban, some fishermen still catch the fish, which Mustafa said is often referred to as "rabbit fish" because it appears to have two teeth at the front of its mouth, similar to a rabbit.

In order to skirt the ban, fishermen sometime cut puffers into strips to hide its main features before selling it to markets as fillet fish, Mustafa said.

"This type [of fish] has been breeding heavily since 2007 in waters surrounding Egypt, and summertime is its mating season, which is why in the past two year, poisoning cases emerged at the same time," Mustafa said.

More oversight needed

In addition, the increase in poisoning cases is exacerbated by a weak oversight system of both fishing practices and marketplace activity, Mustafa said. He also cited a low level of awareness among consumers, many of whom are drawn to lower prices of fish sold by street vendors.

The Fisheries Authority, the Veterinary Association and the Food Inspection Agency, however, are working to prevent the sale of this type of fish in the market, Mustafa said.

"Some inaccurate information about the toxicity of the puffer fish has been circulating," said Dr. Isam Fakhri, a public health and poisoning specialist. "The fish is not poisonous as a whole. The toxins are concentrated in its liver, intestines and skin."

"The poison in the fish is a result of its feeding on poisonous algae and remnants of fish and shellfish, which interact with bacteria inside the fish that is unaffected by cooking, so the majority of poisoning cases result from consuming the cooked fish," he said.

The puffer fish holds enough toxins to poison 100 people, Fakhri said, adding that symptoms begin to appear if an individual consumes even just one milligram of the poison. The symptoms include fainting, vomiting and extended periods of sleep, while some people might suffer from numbness of the face.

If patients report dizziness, vomiting and breathing difficulties, death may be imminent, especially if the proper medication is unavailable, he added

The number of reported deaths caused by eating puffer fish is difficult to confirm because many cases are reported as simple food poisoning, he said.

Only skilled fishermen and cooks can prepare puffer fish

Mohammed al-Gindi, a professor at the Veterinary College of Cairo University, said other poisonous fish are caught off the Egyptian coasts, but puffer fish breed much more sporadically and prefer to live in deep water.

Al-Gindi told Al-Shorfa they can be as long as one meter and weigh up to 12 kilograms. He also said the reduction in fishing during the past couple of years contributed to a reproduction boom.

He added that while the puffer fish is dangerous, it has been eaten in Japan for hundreds of years, where it is called fugu and is highly valued for its taste.

However, only skilled fishermen and cooks can remove the skin and separate the toxic parts from the non-poisonous flesh, he said. If mistakes are made while cleaning the fish, it can cause the poison to seep into other parts and lead to poisoning. He added that the individual cleaning the fish can also be poisoned if he has an open wound.

The poison remains in the body after recovery and takes a long time before it is completely purged, he added.

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS ARTICLE? (TOTAL VOTES: 46)

3 Dislike(s)

ADD A COMMENT (COMMENT POLICY) * DENOTES REQUIRED FIELD

* DENOTES REQUIRED FIELD

  • READER COMMENTS

    مصطفى

    2012-8-10

    The dire economic problems that the people of Egypt are facing have become aggravated, not to mention the educational problems, the widespread problems in the Ministry of Health, the calamities in the Ministry of Housing and Construction, and the terrible qualifications in the Egyptian education. Therefore, we congratulate the Egyptian government on the choice of its new President and we wish him success in fulfilling his duty. Also, we call on him to quickly provide the appropriate solutions to the problems present in the territory of the Arab Republic of Egypt which are vexing the Egyptian citizen’s life, especially the economic problems that are worsening the position of the Egyptian families and make it very difficult. The Egyptian citizen is now suffering from the terrible rise in the price of goods and products and is no longer likely to be able to bear this difficult and bitter expensive living. So we know the kind of difficulty that the new Egyptian government is facing. However, we pray to God the Almighty that this government will be able to serve the citizens and provide the appropriate solutions to help them to live in comfort and bliss.

  • احمد ربيع

    2012-8-7

    May God reward you with goodness! Please post clearer pictures!

  • مقداد

    2012-8-7

    With the existence of investment projects, we ensure the continuity of businesses and ensure the eradication of poverty from our societies as well as work on the improvement of the rest of the other sectors that need a lot of development work such as the health sector, which needs a lot of improvement in terms of providing the technical equipment needed by the public hospitals in addition to the sophisticated analysis factors needed by the poor Egyptian citizen who is in need of free treatment and health care for the people. The coming President has promised that the first priority is the health sector and is working on developing it to suit the citizens especially the needy and the poor people who did not have health insurance.